top of page

DIY All-Time Teams

Public·14 members

All-Time Teams - DIY Strat-o-Matic Teams


114 Views
zafianhome
2 days ago

So I just wanted to provide an overview of my creations: I have made 40 man rosters of who I felt were the best representative players for wach franchise. I put players on only one team although I will have a mixed players set that will include a bunch of players that would have qualified for a second or third team. I chose based on where they would het most playing time. In some cases a player had better years with one team but would be a backup with that team but a starter with another team. All Hall-of-Famers were carded. Also, I only looked at players that qualified for a team based on 20th and 21st century. Any 19th century players were not considered, mostly because the game was so different and so many franchise were defunct. A player like Cap Anson is not carded. But I do plan on adding a 19th century extra players set. The player's record is based on the best 4 consecutive years with that franchise. I used the Neutralized stats from baseball-reference for each player. That way the players are put on a level playing ground regardless of era and ballpark. I did not incorporate ballpark factors or clutch ratings so these are Basic and Advanced Cards, not Super Advanced Cards. In general, the rosters are comprised of 16 pitchers (generally 7 to 10 are starters, most teams are 8 or 9), 3 catchers, 2 of each infield position, 1 additional corner infielder, 1 additional middle infielder and 8 outfielders and 3 designated hitter/other infielder/outfielder/catcher. After choosing the players based on a variety of metrics, I compiled the stats and prorated, lefty-righty stats based on the neutralized stats. I also did my own normalization of fielding stats since fielding stats over time have changed dramatically. I then used Bruce Bundy's formula to create the cards and they are situated to be normalized to the late 70's era. I also plotted each card loosely as per Bundy's layout. You will notice that pitchers and hitters of today will have more strikeouts than those of the early 1900's. Homeruns were scarce with the early 1900's pitchers. All other things being equal, I tended to choose more modern day pitchers to the early 1900's. I did use some rating from strat cards themselves. I took weighted averages on things like, injuries, bunting, hit and run, advanced stealing, power ratings, running ratings for hitters, range and arm ratings for fielders, but e-ratings are my own calculations. For pitchers, hitting/bunting, range, PointOfWeakness (POW), Hold ratings are from cards. Balk and WP are calculated. Each card is hand-crafted....Next steps are as follows: 1. A set of cards (about 40 players) to supplement who would make the rosters now that didn't when I selected the players in 2022 through 2023 (essentially new additions of 2024/2025). Some players in that group were already carded but enhanced their game in those years. This is 80% done. 2. A set of mixed players that qualify for more than one team or more than one position. An example of more than one position is one player, right now, Craig Biggio. I have him as the Astros catcher but his stats are far better at 2nd base. The dilemma is that if I make him 2nd base, how do you play both Altuve and Biggio and also start Alan Ashby rather than a legitimate DH quality player? It was a dilemma that will be solved with a 2nd card for Biggio. These are 25% done. 3. The prior mentioned 19th century 40 man roster. 4. An update of qualifiers for 2026 players. 5. Some pitchers hitting cards, for pitchers who had a significant enough amount of at bats. 6. Roster booklet with stats and ratings 7. Some extra players that have only 3 years and/or some fan choices.

If anybody has any questions or sees any errors please feel free to ask away.

bottom of page